In a recent move that highlights regional geopolitical tensions, the Vietnam government has imposed a ban on a “Barbie” movie due to a controversial map that depicted the disputed “9-dash line” in the South China Sea. Interestingly, while Vietnam deemed the movie problematic, the Philippines Movie and Television Review and Classification Board (MTRCB) did not find it controversial and granted approval for its screening.
Featured image credit: https://www.barbie-themovie.net/
© 2022 WARNER BROS. ENT. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
The “Barbie” movie in question, which featured the disputed map, became a subject of concern for Vietnam’s government, as it depicted the “9-dash line” used by China to claim sovereignty over vast parts of the South China Sea. The “9-dash line” is a highly contentious territorial demarcation that overlaps with the maritime boundaries of several countries including Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia, Brunei, and Taiwan, leading to ongoing disputes and diplomatic tensions in the region.
Citing national security and its position on maritime claims, the Vietnam government swiftly responded by imposing a ban on the movie. The ban was seen as a measure to reaffirm Vietnam’s stance on the issue and avoid potential public controversy surrounding the disputed territory.
However, in a striking contrast, the Philippines MTRCB took a different stance, deeming the movie non-controversial and subsequently granting it approval for release in the country. This decision highlights the divergent interpretations and sensitivities among neighboring countries regarding territorial disputes and the usage of disputed maps in media.
The divergence in responses between Vietnam and the Philippines is a reflection of the complex geopolitical landscape in the South China Sea region. Each nation holds a unique perspective on the territorial disputes and the use of the “9-dash line” on maps, and these differing viewpoints can lead to significant diplomatic and political consequences.
The ban on the “Barbie” movie in Vietnam underscores the government’s commitment to maintaining a firm stance on the maritime dispute. The controversy also sheds light on the ongoing battle over narratives and symbolisms within the public sphere, as portrayal of disputed territories in movies and other forms of media can have far-reaching implications, including territorial claims and national pride.
As the issue gains attention, it serves as a reminder of the complex dynamics involved in territorial disputes and the challenges posed by various interpretations and sensitivities. The controversy surrounding the “Barbie” movie and its divergent treatment by Vietnam and the Philippines MTRCB highlight the need for open dialogue and diplomatic efforts to address the contentious South China Sea disputes and ensure regional stability.
While the ban in Vietnam remains in effect, the film’s release in the Philippines is set to continue, further fueling the ongoing debate surrounding territorial claims and the role of media in shaping public perceptions of regional conflicts.